Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Roadmap For Superblock Feasibility Study

by the Village Board of Nyack

Nyack is embarking on its first tangible step toward the potential redevelopment of the downtown Superblock, the 3.7 acre area that encompasses the Helen Hayes theater building, the M&T bank lot, village owned Veterans Memorial Park and the Village Urban Renewal Agency owned parking lots.

There has long been a sentiment among many in the village that these spaces are both unattractive and tremendously underutilized. This step forward will help establish whether redevelopment of this land is of benefit to the village and, in doing so, will hopefully send us on a path that will include new residential and retail opportunities, more tax rateables, a space that might include arts offerings, additional attractive public space and parking solutions.

The next and exciting step in this process is for the community to work hard and as a whole to determine the appropriate scale, mix of uses and an accurate sense of the financing to create a plan the village afford a plan which doesn’t put taxpayers at risk. This step is officially called a feasibility study.

The Village of Nyack has taken the lead in this process following the impressive commitment over the last two years by the Board of Riverspace to maintain the option on the Helen Hayes building and the M&T bank. They have continued efforts to encourage improvement of the Superblock portion in the heart of our downtown, even after the theater was forced to close its doors because of financial constraints. A member of the Riverspace Board, local Rosie O’Donnell, has agreed to finance the feasibility study. The village has issued a request for proposals (see RFP and supporting materials) for those interested in being chosen to develop the feasibility study.


Until the 1960s, the Superblock was part of Nyack’s downtown which was mixed use with housing and retail. The 1960s and 70s brought the urban renewal program nationwide, with the intention of removing “blight” and accommodating the automobile by adding parking. As happened across the country, the urban renewal program lost its federal funding before the project was completed, so what is now the Superblock has been left unfinished. No major investment has occurred since that time.

Part of the urban renewal project that did  get redeveloped was the Helen Hayes theater, which struggled financially as time went on.  Ultimately, Riverspace took over the theater in 2006, and has since been promoting the idea of redeveloping what is now known as the Superblock with performing arts as the anchor use. Riverspace secured an option on the theater property and the M&T bank property. In response to the recommendations made in the white paper published by the Mayor’s Committee on the Redevelopment of the Superblock, on April 23, 2009, the Village Board passed a resolution which stated its determination that redeveloping the Superblock is in the best interest of the village.

In order to help determine the next steps in the process, the Village of Nyack implemented another recommendation of the white paper and set up a Citizen’s Committee to examine possible uses and configurations for the possible redevelopment project. After an extraordinary amount of research and discussion, the Citizen’s Committee made a number of findings and recommendations in August 2009. Significantly, the committee found that a feasibility study—a professional examination of the site and which combination of uses would best meet the needs of the Village and comport with the Comprehensive Master Plan—was a mandatory first step in any redevelopment that may occur on the Superblock.

The Village Board agreed with this finding and formulated and published a Request For Proposals (RFP). On February 25, 2010, The trustees approved the RFP, and set March 29 as the deadline for proposals. The Village Board will then review the proposals and intends to select a consultant on April 22.

Feasibility Study

The feasibility study is an opportunity for the community to engage in a public process to determine exactly what is the best mix of uses for the site. In the process of evaluating the options, there will be an analysis to determine the financial feasibility of the alternatives and their environmental impact.

The feasibility studies will have three main components:

  1. Use and bulk study — This will evaluate the various uses (arts center, residential, office, retail, parking, public space) to look at the scale, design, and location of structures and public spaces. This will include a public process to run through an iterative process to determine the most appropriate scale and density, and mix of uses.
  2. Market study — The market study will look at the demand for various uses (arts, residential, office, retail) and determine what would be financially feasible. The consultant must have experience with arts, since this will be the anchor use, and has a distinct set of economics.
  3. Traffic/parking analysis — Any development will increase the demand for parking, and the volume of traffic. Each redevelopment scenario needs to be modeled as to the parking requirements and the impact on the road system. The village is asking the consultant to consider innovative, new techniques that can act as alternatives to traditional, structured parking (i.e. a large, parking garage).


Nyack is moving ahead as expeditiously as possible, as well as giving the community ample opportunity to be part of the process and conducting financial due diligence to minimize any risk to Village tax payers.

A review of the project time line:

  • Request for Proposals — Feb 25 to Mar 29
  • Selection of consultant — Apr 22
  • Feasibility studies performed– Apr 22 to Aug 23
  • Analysis of Feasibility Study results begins when final study results received
  • Request for Qualifications (RFQ) for developer — Sept 23 – Oct 25
  • Selection of developer — Nov 25

The roadmap for the Superblock feasibility study was written by Nyack’s Village Board: Mayor Richard Kavesh and Trustees Doug Foster, Steven Knowlton, Louise Parker and Jen Laird White.

Nyack Farmer's Market

You May Also Like

The Villages

This week in the Villages we look at the rumor-filled and then abrupt ending of Starbucks in Nyack and what it means.

The Villages

This week in the Villages, we look delve into all the empty storefronts downtown and look back at St. Patrick's Day festivities through the...

The Villages

This week in the Villages, we take a closer look at Nyack's school board election and more.